* Audition:"Let's Go Round Again" af Patsy Cline
* Hollywood Round 1:"Do I Make You Proud" af Taylor Hicks
* Hollywood Round 2:"I Didn't Know My Own Strength" af Whitney Houston
* Top 24 (semifinaler):"Since U Been Gone" af Kelly Clarkson
* Top 12:"I Want to Be a Cowboy's Sweetheart" af Patsy Montana
* Top 11:"Every Woman in This Town" af Loretta Lynn
* Top 10:"I'm Gonna Love You Through It" af Martina McBride
* Top 9:"A Broken Wing" af Martina McBride
* Top 8:"Crazy" af Patsy Cline
* Top 7:"Red High Heels" af Kellie Pickler (original sang)
* Top 6:"I Still Believe in Love" af Dolly Parton
* Top 5:"Best of My Love" af The Emotions, "Something to Fall Back On" af Whitney Houston og "I Finally Found Someone" af Barbra Streisand
* Top 4:"Behind These Hazel Eyes" af Kelly Clarkson, "I Drove All Night" af Cyndi Lauper og "I Can't Help Myself (Sugar Pie, Honey Bunch)" af The Four Tops
* Top 3:"Do I Make You Proud" af Taylor Hicks, "It's Your Love" af Tim McGraw og Faith Hill og "I'm Sorry" af Brenda Lee
* Finale:"Superstar" af Carpenters, "Best of My Love" af The Emotions og "I Still Believe in Love" af Dolly Parton
Pickler sluttede på sjettepladsen i konkurrencen.