* Tony Award for bedste spil (1947) for "All My Sons"
* Tony Award for bedste forfatter (1950) for "Death of a Salesman"
* New York Drama Critics' Circle Award for bedste skuespil (1947) for "All My Sons"
* New York Drama Critics' Circle Award for bedste skuespil (1949) for "Death of a Salesman"
* Venice Film Festival Award for bedste manuskript (1956) for "The Crucible"
* Golden Globe Award for bedste manuskript (1957) for "The Crucible"
* Academy Award for bedste tilpassede manuskript (1957) for "The Crucible"
* BAFTA-prisen for bedste udenlandske manuskript (1958) for "The Crucible"
* PEN/Malamud Award (1978)
* National Medal of Arts (1986)
* Tony Award for Lifetime Achievement in the Theatre (1993)
* Laurence Olivier-prisen for bedste nye skuespil (1996) for "The Ride Down Mt. Morgan"